Something didn’t add up, so a social worker at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle went looking for a tennis shoe on a ledge outside a hospital window. It’s one of the most talked-about stories in the study of near-death experiences.
It started with a heart patient named Maria, who’d just been resuscitated and was telling people she’d floated out of her body while it happened. Out of the room and, somehow, outside the building. She described a large dark blue tennis shoe with white laces sitting on a ledge out there, and she insisted that the social worker, Kimberly Clark Sharp, go find it. Maria spoke very little English, by the way. Sharp says so herself.
Sharp went looking. We’ll get to how that turned out. But first, let’s be clear about what we’re even talking about, because near-death experiences are a whole lot bigger than one shoe.
Maria’s out-of-body story, as Kimberly Clark Sharp has told it for decades.
“The story has not changed an iota since day one, much less been embellished” — Kimberly Clark Sharp, Journal of Near-Death Studies, on the shoe-on-the-ledge case.
What Is a Near-Death Experience?
A near-death experience, or NDE, is a vivid, often life-changing experience reported by someone who came close to dying or was clinically dead for a short time. People describe leaving their body, moving through darkness toward a light, meeting a being of light or relatives who’ve passed, watching their life replay, and reaching a border they’re told they can’t cross. Then they come back.
Researchers at the University of Virginia’s Division of Perceptual Studies list these as the typical features:
- Out-of-body: a sensation of leaving the body, often while looking down at it.
- Tunnel: being drawn into a tunnel or darkness.
- Light: a brilliant light, sometimes at the end of the tunnel.
- Beings: meeting deceased loved ones or other beings.
- Life review: recalling important events from the past.
- A border: reaching a point they’re told they can’t cross.
- The return: going back to the body, and often coming back changed.
Psychiatrist Raymond Moody put the name on the map with his 1975 book Life After Life, built on interviews with 150 people. The same pieces kept showing up. An overwhelming feeling of peace, the sense of being outside the body, drifting through darkness that some called a tunnel, a golden light, a being of light, a rapid replay of the past, and another world of great beauty. The book sold more than 13 million copies. It started in 1965, when a psychiatrist named George Ritchie told him he believed he’d journeyed into the afterlife while dead for almost nine minutes at age 20.
Researchers wanted something firmer than a list. So in 1983 Bruce Greyson, a psychiatrist at the University of Virginia’s Division of Perceptual Studies, published the Near-Death Experience Scale. He started with a pool of 80 features and boiled it down to 16 items, so you could tell a true NDE from a nonspecific stress reaction. Pretty much every study since uses it or some updated cousin of it.
There’s also a mountain of firsthand stories. Radiation oncologist Jeffrey Long founded the Near-Death Experience Research Foundation in 1998, and NDERF says more than 16,000 experiences are preserved across its three research websites. These are shared stories, not clinical records. Long’s book Evidence of the Afterlife made the New York Times bestseller list, and he says the two words people use most to describe an NDE are peace and love.
That’s the label. Now the stories.
Maria’s Shoe: The Most Famous Verified NDE?
Here’s how Sharp tells it, in her own reply in the Journal of Near-Death Studies. Maria was a cardiac patient who “observed a number of scenes during her resuscitation.” One of them was the shoe. Sharp walked the sidewalk around the building, hunting for something smallish that she couldn’t make out from the ground. Then a bird flew up onto a ledge above her, she lost sight of it, and she went inside to look. She went room to room on the floor above Maria’s, walking up to the glass to look down at the ledges. And she found a tennis shoe.
The mainstream answer is oxygen loss or brain chemistry. In 1996 Skeptical Inquirer ran a piece by Ebbern, Mulligan and Beyerstein saying Maria’s memory was “a visual memory incorporated into the hallucinatory world” of a stressed brain. They also said they could see a running shoe of their own from the ground, and that Maria might’ve overheard somebody mention it.
Sharp’s reply is great, honestly. She says the college students behind that article never even tried to find Maria. She says Maria’s English was nowhere near good enough to follow the details of a shoe’s appearance and location, much less pick them up from hallway chatter. And she says that over the years she’s bumped into three former hospital workers who remember “that patient who saw the shoe on the ledge when she died.”
Is it the cleanest case ever? No. Critics point out she didn’t publish the full details until years later, and honestly it isn’t the best case to hang a whole argument on. Still, nobody has handed us a version where Maria had a normal way of knowing. A woman in the middle of a cardiac arrest, describing a shoe on a ledge she never had a reason to be near.
Where was she looking from?
Looking down at her own body in the hospital bed.
“I was aware of my physical body, I could see it, lying there on that hospital bed, but I was no longer attached to that body.” — Anita Moorjani, TEDx talk, describing her near-death experience.
Pam Reynolds: The Most Verified Near-Death Experience?
If Maria is the folk story, Pam Reynolds is the case people argue about at conferences.
In 1991, Reynolds, a woman from Atlanta, had a brain operation at the Barrow Neurological Institute in Phoenix, performed by surgeon Robert Spetzler. It required a standstill operation. Her body was cooled to 50 degrees Fahrenheit, her heart and breathing stopped, and the blood was drained from her head. Her eyes were taped shut. Small earplugs with speakers sat in her ears, clicking loudly over and over to check her brain stem. For part of that seven-hour operation she had no brain-wave activity and no blood flowing in her brain. Clinically dead, in other words.
Afterward she told the team she’d heard a sound like a “D” natural that seemed to pull her out of her body. She floated above the operating room and watched the doctors work, with vision she said was clearer and more focused than normal. She saw the surgical saw and said it looked like an electric toothbrush. She heard the conversation in the room, even with those clicks blasting in her ears. According to the account on Wikipedia, medical personnel reported that her observations were accurate.
Then the light. She said she was pulled toward it and began to pick out figures, her grandmother, an uncle, and others who’d died, plus some she didn’t know. She was reminded she had to go back, and her uncle brought her back to her body with a feeling like jumping into ice water.
Cardiologist Michael Sabom wrote the case up in his book Light and Death. One critic, Gerald Woerlee, argued that the timing was off and that she picked things up earlier in the operation, before the standstill. People have been going back and forth over those minutes for decades. Reynolds died of heart failure in 2010. She was 53.
Pam Reynolds, in a surgeon’s operating room, watching from above.
“It was the most aware that I think that I have ever been in my entire life … It was brighter and more focused and clearer than normal vision” — Pam Reynolds, describing her 1991 surgery, as quoted from Michael Sabom’s Light and Death.
What Do the Big Hospital Studies Say?
This is where it gets interesting, because the people who went looking were doctors.
In 2001, cardiologist Pim van Lommel and his team published a study in The Lancet. They followed 344 consecutive cardiac patients resuscitated in ten Dutch hospitals. Sixty-two of them, 18 percent, reported an NDE, and 41 described a core experience. What made people sit up was that having one didn’t line up with how long the heart had been stopped, how long the person was unconscious, or how afraid of dying they’d been beforehand. The team compared the groups two years later and again at eight years. The people who’d had an NDE were changed, and the change took years to settle.
They also wrote a line that’s hard to shrug off. “With a purely physiological explanation such as cerebral anoxia for the experience, most patients who have been clinically dead should report one.” Most don’t. So what’s different about the ones who do?
Then came AWARE, led by Sam Parnia. The 2014 version covered 2,060 cardiac arrests at multiple hospitals and ended up interviewing 101 survivors. Forty-six percent had some memory from the time they were out, with themes like fear, bright light, family, and violence or persecution. Nine percent had a full NDE. And 2 percent described actually seeing and hearing real events from their own resuscitation. One of them had a verifiable period of conscious awareness at a time when the brain wasn’t expected to be working.
Now, I’ll be straight about the part that didn’t pan out. Researchers hung pictures on high shelves in some rooms, hoping a floating patient would read them. In the 2023 follow-up, AWARE II, nobody identified the image, and only one of 28 interviewed survivors identified a sound they’d played. So far, nobody has read the secret shelf.
But AWARE II turned up something else. It ran in 25 hospitals, with brain monitors on during CPR. Out of 567 in-hospital cardiac arrests, 53 people survived and 28 completed interviews. Eleven of the 28 had memories that suggested consciousness, and six described what the team calls a “recalled experience of death,” the classic NDE. And here’s the line I keep rereading. Despite marked cerebral ischemia, which basically means badly reduced blood flow to the brain, “normal EEG activity… consistent with consciousness emerged as long as 35-60 minutes into CPR.”
Thirty-five to sixty minutes. Into CPR. You’d think that wouldn’t be possible, and the (quote unquote) “experts” spent a long time saying exactly that. I’d love to hear them explain it without using the word “somehow.”
The monitors kept running while patients recalled what happened.
“…normal EEG activity (delta, theta and alpha) consistent with consciousness emerged as long as 35-60 minutes into CPR.” — Sam Parnia and colleagues, Resuscitation, AWARE II study, 2023.
So What Does Science Say Causes Near-Death Experiences?
Fair question, and not everybody asking it is out to debunk anybody. Researchers have three main ideas, so let’s give each one a hearing.
The oldest is oxygen loss. The heart stops, the brain starves, and a starving brain does strange things. Brain chemistry usually gets tossed into the same bucket. Van Lommel’s team already pushed back on that in The Lancet, but it’s still the default answer.
The second is REM intrusion. In a 2006 paper in Neurology, Nelson and his colleagues suggested that pieces of dream sleep can break into waking awareness when the body is in danger. They compared 55 people who’d had an NDE with matched controls and found that sleep paralysis, and sleep-related visual and auditory hallucinations, were substantially more common in the NDE group. Nelson’s own wording is that REM intrusion “could promote subjective aspects” of an NDE. Hold onto that word, subjective.
The third is the dying-brain surge, and honestly it’s the one I find most interesting. In 2013, Borjigin‘s team at the University of Michigan recorded brain waves in rats during experimental cardiac arrest. Within the first 30 seconds after the heart stopped, they saw a brief surge of synchronized gamma activity, right before the signal went flat, and it exceeded what the brain does when it’s wide awake. The authors wrote that the brain “can, albeit paradoxically, generate neural correlates of heightened conscious processing at near-death.” In 2023 the same group reported that two of four comatose dying patients showed a similar gamma surge after their ventilators were withdrawn, including in a back region of the cortex they call the “hot zone.”
That’s real science, and I’m not going to wave it away. But look at where it stops. A surge in the first half-minute after a heart stops, in rats, is a long way from Pam Reynolds, whose brain waves were reported absent while clicking earplugs checked her brain stem. It’s a long way from AWARE II too, where normal brain activity showed up 35 to 60 minutes into CPR.
Walking toward the light at the end of the dark.
“…feels himself moving very rapidly through a long dark tunnel.” — Raymond Moody, psychiatrist and author of Life After Life, describing the typical experience.
And look at what’s actually being measured. Gamma waves, dream intrusion and a starving brain are candidates for the feeling, the light, the peace. Nelson himself says subjective. None of them tells you where a tennis shoe is sitting on a ledge outside a window, or what a surgical saw looks like to a woman with her eyes taped shut. The Michigan study recorded signals, not experiences.
Maybe the surge is the door swinging open. What’s standing on the other side of it is the part nobody has measured.
Doctors and Nurses Have Them Too
It’d be easy to assume only patients tell these stories. Nope.
Tony Cicoria was an orthopedic surgeon in upstate New York in 1994 when a bolt of lightning hit him next to a public telephone. He remembers seeing his own body on the ground, surrounded by a bluish-white light. His heart apparently stopped. A woman waiting to use the phone started resuscitating him, and, coincidence or not, she turned out to be an intensive-care-unit nurse. A few weeks later he was struck by an insatiable desire to hear piano music. He taught himself to play, and ended up composing. Neurologist Oliver Sacks wrote about him in Musicophilia. Pretty wild, a surgeon who’d never cared about music turning into a pianist.
What About Cops, Paramedics and Soldiers?
I went looking for documented stories from first responders and the military, and honestly, formal studies of police officers or firefighters having NDEs are thin. What exists is on-the-record interviews, news reports, and one old research project on combat veterans. So here’s what I can actually verify.
Dallas detective Ed Lujan. On November 9, 2015, Lujan was working off duty in uniform at a nightclub in northwest Dallas when a man ran him over with an SUV, according to police, then backed up and ran him over again, then drove forward and did it a third time. His injuries included a broken neck, shattered hips and a head wound where you could see his skull. He told WFAA that as he lay there, “I felt the euphoria of my life and soul leaving my body.” It wasn’t sadness or joy. “It was more like tranquility.”
Then he saw his father, who had died eight years earlier, standing over him. “Son, you have to get up because you have a family that loves you and needs you.” Lujan told him, “Dad, I can’t get up.” Next came a deep breath, the feeling of his soul re-entering his body, and then he was waking up on the way to the hospital. A working cop in uniform, with nothing to gain by telling it, and what he remembers is peace. That gets under my skin a little.
Mount Vernon, Washington, officer Mike McClaughry. He was shot in the head while responding to a call. About a year later he told FOX 13 Seattle about floating in what he called a “nether world,” watching a dark spot grow larger in front of him. Then a message, which he put into words himself. “You don’t get to go there, not yet. You have more to do.” To be fair, McClaughry was in a coma, not declared dead, and he describes it as a spiritual experience, not an NDE. Even so, as of that interview he still hadn’t regained his vision, and this is what he chose to talk about.
Paramedic Adam Tapp. A Canadian paramedic, electrocuted in 2018 while woodworking, was revived 11 minutes later after two defibrillator shocks. He told the story publicly, and 7NEWS reported it. He saw flashes of iridescent color, then “this perfect inky blackness. It was almost like deep space, where there were like these lights in the distance like these twinkling stars.” No fear at all. After eight hours in a coma, he woke up and scribbled a note asking how long he’d been out. If someone had told him five years or a decade, he said, he’d have believed it.
Combat veterans. In 1984, Anabiosis: The Journal for Near-Death Studies published a preliminary investigation of combat-related NDEs. More than 100 veterans had replied, all of them men, and the researcher had collected 24 combat NDEs from World War II, Korea and Vietnam. One was a 19-year-old infantryman shot in the chest. After surgery, while still apparently unconscious, he felt himself floating about three feet above the doctors and nurses, under the most beautiful blue sky he’d ever seen, with an intensely bright but soft light. A gentle voice asked why he wanted to return. “To complete my purpose in life,” he said. Then he heard the nurse say, “Thank God, you’re back, we almost gave you up.” He told only a handful of people about it over the years.
Another account came from a Vietnam veteran in 1968, called “Tom” in the paper. He stepped on a land mine. Everything went into slow motion, he said, and he felt himself drawn up through a tube with a bright light at the end. On the ground below he could see the body of his squad leader and hear the gurgling from his throat wound. He felt he was “cradled in the arms of God.” He didn’t want to come back, and when he did he pounded the ground in anger. When he tried to tell the medic, the medic made him stay down. Later, a doctor told him, “Don’t worry, your head will clear up.”
Of course. The doctor had a diagnosis ready before Tom finished his sentence.
A father’s voice on a Dallas sidewalk.
“The next thing that happens is I see my father … He is standing on the same sidewalk I was standing on and he’s looking down at me and he tells me ‘son, get up’” — Detective Ed Lujan, Dallas police, speaking to CBS Texas.
A soldier’s account of being drawn up through a tube of light.
“It was as if I was being cradled in the arms of God.” — “Tom,” a Vietnam veteran, in Robert M. Sullivan’s 1984 study of combat NDEs.
Do Children Have Near-Death Experiences?
According to a Seattle pediatrician named Melvin Morse, they do. Morse did his pediatrics residency at Seattle Children’s Hospital and later taught at the University of Washington, and in the mid-1980s he started interviewing kids who’d come back from the worst.
His first paper, in the American Journal of Diseases of Children in 1985, looked at seven children who survived cardiopulmonary arrests or comas after things like trauma and drowning. Four of the seven reported a near-death experience. They described being out of the body, traveling in a tunnel or up a staircase, seeing beings dressed in white, and deciding to return. The authors said they knew of no earlier medical studies of these experiences in children.
The bigger study came in November 1986. Morse and his colleagues interviewed 11 patients, aged 3 through 16, who’d survived critical illnesses including cardiac arrests and profound comas. Seven had memories of the time they were unconscious. Six described being out of the physical body, five entering darkness, four a tunnel, and three deciding to return. They also interviewed 29 age-matched children who’d been seriously ill in intensive care. None of them remembered anything from the time they were out.
Rising toward the clouds.
“The intensity, depth, and purity of these feelings and sensations were far greater than I could ever describe with words and far greater than anything I have ever experienced on earth.” — Mary Neal, orthopedic surgeon and author of To Heaven and Back, on her 1999 drowning experience.
The paper adds that no child described depersonalization, and that the elements they reported were similar to the ones adults describe. Its authors suggested that “a core NDE, triggered by the process of dying or resuscitation efforts, may be a natural developmental experience.” Morse went on to write Closer to the Light with Paul Perry, a New York Times bestseller that covers 26 children, and a 1994 review in Current Problems in Pediatrics on near-death experiences and death-related visions in children, written for doctors.
Here’s why believers lean on this. A seven-year-old hasn’t spent a lifetime soaking up movies and sermons about tunnels and bright lights, yet the accounts line up with the grown-up ones. That’s the argument, anyway. To be fair, eleven kids is a small group, and Morse’s 1985 paper itself says further systematic study is needed.
Three of those kids said they decided to come back. I’m still chewing on that one.
Did the Ancients Write About This Too?
This part makes me lean forward. People were writing down near-death experiences long before anyone owned a defibrillator.
Plato‘s Myth of Er. At the end of the Republic, Plato tells the story of a soldier named Er from Pamphylia, killed in battle. When the bodies were gathered up ten days later, his hadn’t decayed. Two days after that he revived on his funeral pyre and told everyone what he’d seen. He’d come to a place with four openings, two in the sky and two in the ground, with judges telling souls where to go. But when Er stepped up, he was told to stay and watch so he could report back to humankind. A dead soldier who returns to deliver a message. Sounds familiar.
Drythelm of Northumbria. In his Ecclesiastical History, Bede tells of a family man from the Cuningham district who got sick and “died in the beginning of the night,” then suddenly came back to life early the next morning. Everyone around his body fled in fright, except his wife. The translation dates it to A.D. 696. He said a guide with “a shining countenance and a bright garment” led him silently through a vast valley with flames on one side and hail and snow on the other, then through darkness where globes of black fire rose out of a pit. Dark spirits “threatened to lay hold on me with burning tongs.” Then a light like a star drove them off, and the guide led him “into an atmosphere of clear light.” There was a wall with no door, and somehow they ended up on top of it, over a field of fragrant flowers. Afterward he gave his money away and joined the monastery at Melrose. That’s the whole template, and it’s from the 700s.
The Tibetan Book of the Dead. Its real title is the Bardo Thodol, “Liberation through hearing during the intermediate state.” Tradition says it was composed in the 8th century and found by Karma Lingpa in the 14th. It walks through what consciousness meets in the bardo between death and rebirth. The first stage, the chikhai bardo, “bardo of the moment of death,” features the “clear light of reality.” Next come visions of Buddha forms, then karmic hallucinations that lead toward rebirth. Walter Evans-Wentz‘s edition, the one the West knows, appeared in 1927. A text meant to be heard by the dying, and it opens with a clear light.
Emanuel Swedenborg. The Swedish scientist turned visionary published Heaven and Hell in 1758, and its Latin subtitle means “from things heard and seen.” After 1745 he considered himself to be in a spiritual state. There’s also the famous report from July 19, 1759. Dining in Gothenburg, roughly 400 kilometers from Stockholm, he supposedly announced a fire in the capital and said it had stopped three doors from his own house. Messengers later confirmed it to the hour. The details change depending on who’s telling it, so take that with a grain of salt.
Hieronymus Bosch‘s Ascent of the Blessed. Painted between 1505 and 1515 and now in Venice, it shows angels helping human souls up toward heaven. Not every scholar agrees it’s by Bosch, but some NDE researchers connect it to near-death features.
I’m not saying all of these are the same thing. Plato’s Greece and eighth-century Tibet didn’t compare notes. But a guide, a light, a boundary, an order to go back… that’s what Moody’s patients were saying in the 1970s.
Past the body, the room and the stars.
“It was this perfect inky blackness. It was almost like deep space, where there were like these lights in the distance like these twinkling stars.” — Adam Tapp, paramedic, speaking to 7NEWS.
Clouds, light and a long way up.
“…I was in a place of clouds. Big, puffy, pink-white ones that showed up sharply against the deep blue-black sky.” — Eben Alexander, neurosurgeon and author of Proof of Heaven, in Newsweek.
The dark tunnel, and the light at the end of it.
“The light was incredibly bright, like sitting in the middle of a lightbulb.” — Pam Reynolds, quoted from Michael Sabom’s Light and Death.
Are All Near-Death Experiences Peaceful?
No. Some people come back terrified, and I’d be leaving out a piece of the lore if I only told the beautiful ones.
Drythelm had a version of it, with those black flames and the burning tongs. In the modern research, the AWARE study listed violence and persecution among its seven themes, next to fear. And in a 2014 paper in Missouri Medicine, Nancy Evans Bush and Bruce Greyson wrote about distressing NDEs. Because the idea of hell is so deeply rooted in Western culture, they said, these experiences pose serious challenges to the people who have to build their lives around them. Their advice to physicians was neutrality and careful listening.
What Changes After a Near-Death Experience?
Maybe the strangest part is what happens afterward. Psychologist Kenneth Ring found a consistent set of changes in people who’d had one, including a greater appreciation for life, more compassion, less concern about acquiring money, and no more worrying about death. Van Lommel’s team saw something similar in the Netherlands. The transformation took several years, and it looked different from survivors of cardiac arrest who hadn’t had an NDE.
Other Strange Pieces of the Puzzle
Two other phenomena share features with near-death experiences. I’m not saying they’re connected. I just think the parallels are fun.
Deathbed visions. The physicist William F. Barrett, who founded the Society for Psychical Research, collected accounts of dying people who saw dead friends and relatives in his book Death-Bed Visions, published in 1926. Inside that lore is a special category called “Peak in Darien” cases, named after an 1882 collection of essays by Frances Power Cobbe. These are cases where a dying person seems to see someone whose death they hadn’t been told about. Greyson compiled several examples in a 2010 paper. Critics say the accounts are retrospective and anecdotal. The pattern keeps showing up anyway.
The Third Man Factor. Ernest Shackleton wrote in his 1919 book South, about a 36-hour march across South Georgia, that “it seemed to me often that we were four, not three.” Climber Joe Simpson described a voice that encouraged and directed him as he crawled to base camp after falling into a crevasse, and Reinhold Messner has reported the phenomenon too. John Geiger collected scores of cases in his 2009 book. It tends to show up when someone is truly at the edge, same as an NDE.
So What Do We Make of It?
Honestly? I’m not going to pretend I’ve got the answer. But look at what’s on the table. A shoe that a patient insisted was out on a ledge. A man in Phoenix whose brain was supposedly silent. A detective on a Dallas sidewalk talking to his dead father. A soldier told his head would clear up. A monk in the 700s. And a 2023 study that saw normal brain activity as long as an hour into CPR.
A lot of these folks got shut down the first time they opened their mouths, like Tom did. They’re still talking.
What do you think? Have you or someone you know had one? Let me know in the comments.
Reaching for the light.
“It is tangible; you can feel it. It is alluring; you want to go to it like you would want to go to your ideal mother’s or father’s arms.” — Mellen-Thomas Benedict, describing his 1982 near-death experience.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a near-death experience (NDE)?
A near-death experience is a vivid experience reported by someone who came close to dying or was clinically dead for a short time. Common features include leaving the body, moving toward a light, meeting a being of light or deceased relatives, reviewing one’s life, and being told to go back. Raymond Moody put the term on the map with Life After Life in 1975.
What happens during a near-death experience?
People commonly report leaving the body, moving through darkness toward a bright light, meeting deceased relatives or a being of light, reviewing their lives and reaching a border they’re told they can’t cross before returning. Raymond Moody described these features in Life After Life in 1975, and Bruce Greyson’s scale measures them.
How common are near-death experiences?
It depends how you define them. In van Lommel’s Dutch study of 344 resuscitated cardiac patients, 18 percent reported an NDE. In the 2014 AWARE study, 9 percent of interviewed survivors did.
What is the most credible near-death experience case?
There’s no official ranking, but Pam Reynolds is the case people argue about most. In 1991 she had brain surgery at the Barrow Neurological Institute and afterward described details of the operation, according to Michael Sabom’s account. Critics such as Gerald Woerlee dispute the timing, so it remains contested.
Can near-death experiences be explained scientifically?
The mainstream points to oxygen loss or brain chemistry. Some researchers, including van Lommel, say that doesn’t fit what they found. In his Lancet study, an NDE wasn’t tied to how long the heart was stopped, and in AWARE II, normal brain activity showed up 35 to 60 minutes into CPR.
Are there documented near-death experiences from police officers or soldiers?
Yes, though formal research is limited. Dallas detective Ed Lujan and Washington officer Mike McClaughry gave news interviews, and a 1984 paper in Anabiosis: The Journal for Near-Death Studies collected 24 combat NDEs from World War II, Korea and Vietnam veterans.
Can a near-death experience be dark or distressing?
Yes. Most reports are peaceful, but some people describe experiences that were frightening or even hellish. In a 1992 paper in Psychiatry, Bruce Greyson and Nancy Evans Bush described three types of distressing NDE. One has the usual features but the person found them unpleasant. One is a sense of nonexistence or an eternal void. One has graphic hellish landscapes and beings. The first type can later turn into a peaceful experience. In a 2014 paper in Missouri Medicine, the same pair wrote that because the idea of hell is so deeply rooted in Western culture, these experiences pose serious challenges to the people who have to live with them, and they advised doctors to stay neutral and listen carefully. The AWARE study also found fear and persecution among its themes.
Did people write about near-death experiences before modern medicine?
They did. Plato’s Myth of Er, Bede’s story of Drythelm, the Tibetan Bardo Thodol and the visions of Swedenborg all describe journeys through death with guides, light and a boundary. Whether they describe the same thing is open.
Keep Exploring the Weird
If you like this kind of rabbit hole, join the free newsletter at crypticchronicles.com, one email a week with the strangest story on my mind and the newest episode. And if you want the full extended episodes, the Chronicler’s Vault on Patreon starts at five bucks. Either way, thanks for reading.
Sources
- Moody, Raymond. Life After Life (1975): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_After_Life_(Moody_book)
- Raymond Moody biography: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_Moody
- Near-death experience overview (features, aftereffects, Kenneth Ring): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Near-death_experience
- Greyson, B. “The near-death experience scale. Construction, reliability, and validity.” J Nerv Ment Dis, 1983: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6854303/
- Sharp, K. C. “The Other Shoe Drops: Commentary on ‘Does Paranormal Perception Occur in Near-Death Experiences?'” Journal of Near-Death Studies, vol. 25, no. 4: https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc798924/m2/1/high_res_d/vol25-no4-245.pdf
- IANDS post on Kimberly Clark Sharp and the shoe: https://www.facebook.com/IANDS.NDE/posts/kimberly-clark-sharp-describes-the-moment-when-she-verified-the-existence-of-a-s/2231041063613993/
- Pam Reynolds case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pam_Reynolds_case
- van Lommel P, et al. “Near-death experience in survivors of cardiac arrest: a prospective study in the Netherlands.” The Lancet, 2001: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11755611/
- Parnia S, et al. “AWARE—AWAreness during REsuscitation—a prospective study.” Resuscitation, 2014: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25301715/
- Parnia S, et al. “AWAreness during REsuscitation – II.” Resuscitation, 2023: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37423492/
- Tony Cicoria: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Cicoria
- “Dallas officer describes spiritual brush with afterlife,” WFAA: https://www.wfaa.com/article/news/local/dallas-county/dallas-officer-describes-spiritual-brush-with-afterlife/287-419658121
- “Dallas Police Detective Recovering From Near Death Experience,” CBS Texas: https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/dallas-police-detective-recovering-from-near-death-experience/
- “Mount Vernon officer who had been shot in head describes what he saw while in coma,” FOX 13 Seattle, Dec. 16, 2017: https://www.fox13seattle.com/news/mount-vernon-officer-who-had-been-shot-in-head-describes-what-he-saw-while-in-coma
- “Paramedic revived 11 minutes after electrocution details his ‘tranquil’ near-death experience,” 7NEWS: https://7news.com.au/lifestyle/paramedic-revived-11-minutes-after-electrocution-details-his-tranquil-near-death-experience-c-17301712
- “Combat-related near-death experiences: A preliminary investigation,” Anabiosis: The Journal for Near-Death Studies, vol. 4, no. 2, 1984: https://doi.org/10.17514/jnds-1984-4-2-p143-152 and https://digital.library.unt.edu/ark:/67531/metadc1043896/m1/45/
- Myth of Er (Plato, Republic 10.614-621): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_Er
- Bede, Ecclesiastical History, Book V, ch. 12 (Fordham Internet History Sourcebooks): https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/basis/bede-book5.asp
- Drythelm: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drythelm
- Bardo Thodol: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bardo_Thodol
- Emanuel Swedenborg: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emanuel_Swedenborg
- Bosch, Ascent of the Blessed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ascent_of_the_Blessed
- Bush NE, Greyson B. “Distressing near-death experiences: the basics.” Missouri Medicine, 2014: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25665233/
- Deathbed phenomena (Barrett, Peak in Darien): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deathbed_phenomena
- William Fletcher Barrett: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Fletcher_Barrett
- Third man factor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_man_factor
- Borjigin J, et al. “Surge of neurophysiological coherence and connectivity in the dying brain.” PNAS, 2013: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23940340/
- Xu G, et al. “Surge of neurophysiological coupling and connectivity of gamma oscillations in the dying human brain.” PNAS, 2023: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37126719/
- Morse M, Conner D, Tyler D. “Near-death experiences in a pediatric population. A preliminary report.” Am J Dis Child, 1985: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4003364/
- Morse M, et al. “Childhood near-death experiences.” Am J Dis Child, 1986: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3020964/
- Morse ML. “Near death experiences and death-related visions in children: implications for the clinician.” Curr Probl Pediatr, 1994: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8026218/
- Melvin L. Morse (training, career, Closer to the Light): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melvin_L._Morse
- Near-Death Experience Research Foundation (NDERF): https://www.nderf.org/
- Jeffrey Long (founder of NDERF, Evidence of the Afterlife): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeffrey_Long
- Greyson B, Bush NE. “Distressing near-death experiences.” Psychiatry, 1992: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1557473/
0 Comments